The Queen of Sheba

The queen of Sheba is a surprisingly mysterious figure the story of Shlomo HaMelech. Her story is repeated twice, once in Melachim I and once in Divrei Hayamim II. The commentaries explain why she came,

(א) ומלכת שבא פי' מהרי''א שעבדי שלמה אשר הלכו באניות אופירה עברו בדרכם דרך ארץ שבא שהים הסובב אותה מתחבר עם ים סוף בצד מערב והם ספרו חכמת שלמה, והיא (ב) שמעה שמעו לשם ה' ר''ל שחכמתו היא אלהית, לא טבעית (ג) ותבא לנסותו בחדות, כי א''א בחכמה אנושית לבד להגיד כל החדות שלפעמים ענינם נעלם כמו חדתו של שמשון, שלא היה אפשר להגידה כי מי ינבא שהרג ארי ושקננו בגויתו עדת דבורים ודבש :

(א) לשם ה׳. רוצה לומר: שמעה אשר חכמתו איננה מטבע האנושי, כי אם מה׳ היתה לו: (ב) לנסותו בחידות. לשאלו דברים סתומים קשה הידיעה, ואם יגידם, תדע נאמנה שמאת ה׳ היתה לו החכמה:

She heard of Shlomo's legendary greatness and wanted to test it for herself. She wanted to see if it was normal or God-given, if he was truly the wisest in the world. According to Ralbag,

(א) ומלכת שבא שמעת את שמע שלמה לשם ה'. ר''ל שהיא היתה שומעת את שמע חכמת שלמה לשם ה' והרצון בו כי מה' היתה לו החכמה כמו שקדם באמרו הנני נתתי לך לב חכם ונבון אשר כמוך לא היה לפניך ויהיה הרצון באמרו לשם ה' בעבור שם ה' או יהיה הרצון בזה שהיא שמעה שמעו שכל מה שהיה עושה היה עושה לשם ה' ולזה היה דבק בו תמיד והפליג מפני זה בחכמה כי זה אחד מהכלים הגדולי' להשגת החכמ' או ירצה בזה שהיתה לו חכמה נפלאה ולא היה משתמש בה אלא לשם ה' לעשות צדקה ומשפט כמו שמצאנו מהזונות שבאו לפניו ומהבאור הראשון הוא יותר נכון לפי מה שאחשוב: (ב) ותבא לנסותו בחידות. לבחון חכמתו אם יעמוד על סוד החידות ההם אשר כונה בהם כי בזה יבחן את החכמה היא לו מתת אלקים שאם הענין כן יעמוד על הכוונה אשר כוונה בהם ואע''פ שהם יסבלו כוונות אחרות:

She wanted to see if he believed his wisdom to truly be from Hashem and if he used it solely for righteousness and justice like she'd heard. Shlomo HaMelech was an anomaly in his time, righteous while all the other rulers were corrupt and self-serving.

For the most part, commentaries agree about what she heard that caused her to come, but the real mystery is who she was. What was her name? Where is Sheba really? What was her true purpose? Why is she so mysterious? And why is she important enough to be mentioned twice (Melachim and Divrei Hayamim)?

א"ר שמואל בר נחמני א"ר יונתן כל האומר מלכת שבא אשה היתה אינו אלא טועה מאי מלכת שבא מלכותא דשבא

Rabbi Shmuel bar Naḥmani says that Rabbi Yonatan says: Anyone who says that the queen of Sheba [malkat Sheva] who came to visit King Solomon (see I Kings, chapter 10) was a woman is nothing other than mistaken. What is the meaning of malkat Sheba? The kingdom [malkhuta] of Sheba, as is mentioned in Job: “And Sheba fell on them and took them away” (Job 1:15).

Although the Gemara is adamant that the Queen of Sheba is not a real person, there are many other Jewish sources that do not agree. Among them is the Shenei Luchot Habrit which says:

(עג) אבל כשבא שלמה וקיימא סיהרא באשלמותא, וכל המלכים היו מביאים איש מנחתו וירית סיהרא מכל סיטרהא, ומלך ושלט על המזיקין, ואשמדאי יוכיח, ועובדא דמלכת שבא כדאיתא בתרגום שני של מגלת אסתר ששלח לומר לה אם לא תכנעי תחתי אשלח לך שדין ורוחין ולילין שיהרגו אותך על מטתך וכו',

(73) When king Solomon ascended the throne of Israel and the glory of Israel was at its height, kings from all over the world came to bring him presents, and he inherited the crown of every domain including the domains ruled over by the various demons. According to a version in the Targum Sheni on the Book of Esther, Solomon sent a threatening letter to the queen of Sheba warning her that if she would not come and submit to his rule, he would dispatch all kinds of demons who would kill her while she was asleep.

The Legends of the Jews, for its opinion on the matter, quotes this Targum Sheni nearly identically (a translation of Targum Sheni can be found in the Appendix to An Explanatory Commentary on Esther by Professor Paulus Cassel, 1888):

(51) Solomon, it must be remembered, bore rule not only over men, but also over the beasts of the field, the birds of the air, demons, spirits, and the spectres of the night. He knew the language of all of them and they understood his language.

(52) When Solomon was of good cheer by reason of wine, he summoned the beasts of the field, the birds of the air, the creeping reptiles, the shades, the spectres, and the ghosts, to perform their dances before the kings, his neighbors, whom he invited to witness his power and greatness. The king's scribes called the animals and the spirits by name, one by one, and they all assembled of their own accord, without fetters or bonds, with no human hand to guide them.

(53) On one occasion the hoopoe was missed from among the birds. He could not be found anywhere. The king, full of wrath, ordered him to be produced and chastised for his tardiness. The hoopoe appeared and said: "O lord, king of the world, incline thine ear and hearken to my words. Three months have gone by since I began to take counsel with myself and resolve upon a course of action. I have eaten no food and drunk no water, in order to fly about in the whole world and see whether there is a domain anywhere which is not subject to my lord the king. and I found a city, the city of Kitor, in the East. Dust is more valuable than gold there, and silver is like the mud of the streets. Its trees are from the beginning of all time, and they suck up water that flows from the Garden of Eden. The city is crowded with men. On their heads they wear garlands wreathed in Paradise. They know not how to fight, nor how to shoot with bow and arrow. Their ruler is a woman, she is called the Queen of Sheba. If, now, it please thee, O lord and king, I shall gird my loins like a hero, and journey to the city of Kitor in the land of Sheba. Its kings I shall fetter with chains and its rulers with iron bands, and bring them all before my lord the king."

(54) The hoopoe's speech pleased the king. The clerks of his land were summoned, and they wrote a letter and bound it to the hoopoe's wing. The bird rose skyward, uttered his cry, and flew away, followed by all the other birds.

(55) And they came to Kitor in the land of Sheba. It was morning, and the queen had gone forth to pay worship to the sun. Suddenly the birds darkened his light. The queen raised her hand, and rent her garment, and was sore astonished. Then the hoopoe alighted near her. Seeing that a letter was tied to his wing, she loosed it and read it. And what was written in the letter? "From me, King Solomon! Peace be with thee, peace with the nobles of thy realm! Know that God has appointed me king over the beasts of the field, the birds of the air, the demons, the spirits, and the spectres. All the kings of the East and the West come to bring me greetings. If thou wilt come and salute me, I shall show thee great honor, more than to any of the kings that attend me. But if thou wilt not pay homage to me, I shall send out kings, legions, and riders against thee. Thou askest, who are these kings, legions, and riders of King Solomon? The beasts of the field are my kings, the birds my riders, the demons, spirit, and shades of the night my legions. The demons will throttle you in your beds at night, while the beasts will slay you in the field, and the birds will consume your flesh."

(56) When the Queen of Sheba had read the contents of the letter, she again rent her garment, and sent word to her elders and her princes: "Know you not what Solomon has written to me?" They answered: "We know nothing of King Solomon, and his dominion we regard as naught." But their words did not reassure the queen. She assembled all the ships of the sea, and loaded them with the finest kinds of wood, and with pearls and precious stones. Together with these she sent Solomon six thousand youths and maidens, born in the same year, in the same month, on the same day, in the same hour all of equal stature and size, all clothed in purple garments. They bore a letter to King Solomon as follows: "From the city of Kitor to the land of Israel is a journey of seven years. As it is thy wish and behest that I visit thee, I shall hasten and be in Jerusalem at the end of three years."

According to the Targum Sheni, the Queen of Sheba was a queen who was basically forced to submit to Shlomo, due to his power over the demons. Before she would agree to submit to Shlomo HaMelech however, she needed proof of his divine wisdom. This is why she comes with questions to challenge Shlomo. After he answers her questions (which we'll get into later), she praises Hashem, Shlomo, and the Jews for their wisdom and goodness and agrees to give tribute to Shlomo.

In Kabbalah and the Zohar, based on Targum Iyov , the Queen of Sheba is not identified as a person, but the queen of demons, Lilith. Otherwise, she is a sorceress or a demonic seductress.

(סג)... אֲבָל חָכְמָתוֹ עִם מַלְכַּת שְׁבָא וְזוּלָתָם לֹא זָכַר, כִּי לֹא הָיְתָה כַוָּנַת הַכּוֹתֵב לִזְכֹּר...

(63)... The wisdom he displayed in his intercourse with the Queen of Sheba and elsewhere is not mentioned, because it was not the author's intention to relate anything...

In a lost Midrash that is often quoted by early sources, including this Kuzari, Shlomo convinced the Queen to convert to Judaism, and married her, but was not able to convince her to stay. She ended up going back to her country, but she was pregnant. According to Jewish sources, starting with the Toldot Ben Sira, this child either was or was ancestor to Nevuchadnezzar.

There is much disagreement on where Sheba actually is. According to Ethiopian tradition and folklore (and supported by the Me'am Loez and Josephus), the Queen of Sheba was from Ethiopia and her name was Nicaulis or Makeda. They believe the child of Shlomo and the Queen was named Menalik, and is the ancestor of the Ethiopian kings. Josephus also quotes the possibility that she was queen over Egypt as well. The Arabs believe that she was from Arabia and that her name was Bilkis. They believe she ended up recognizing the truth of Shlomo's religion and accepted his faith.

Clearly, the Queen of Sheba is an incredibly mysterious figure. Most sources on her are impossible to find, and those that can be found are conflicting and quote other unfindable sources. However, almost all sources agree on the ways she tested Shlomo's wisdom.

(א)... ד"א "והחכמה מאין תימצא" - זה מלכת שבא, ששמעה את חכמתו, אמרה 'אלך ואראה אם חכם הוא אם לאו', ומניין ששמעה חכמתו? שנאמר (מלכים א י א): "ומלכת שבא שומעת את שמע שלמה לשם ה' ותבוא לנסותו בחידות", מהו בחידות? אמר רבי ירמיה בר שלום: אמרה לו 'אתה הוא שלמה, ששמעתי עליך ועל מלכותך ועל חכמתך?', אמר לה 'הן', אמרה לו 'חכם גדול אתה, אלא אם אני שואלת ממך דבר אחד, אתה משיב לי?', אמר לה (משלי ב ו): "כי ה' יתן חכמה, מפיו דעת ותבונה". אמרה לו 'מה הן שבעה יוצאין, ותשעה נכנסין, ושניים מוזגים, ואחד שותה?' אמר לה 'בוודאי, שבעה ימי נידה יוצאין, ותשעה ירחי לידה נכנסין, שני דדיים מוזגים, והוולד שותה'. אמרה לו 'חכם גדול אתה, אלא אם אני שואלת ממך דבר אחר אתה משיבני?' אמר לה "כי ה' יתן חכמה", אמרה לו 'מה הוא, אשה אמרה לבנה: אביך - אבי, זקנך - בעלי, ואת - ברי, ואנא - אחותך'? אמר לה 'בוודאי, שתי בנותיו של לוט הן'. ועוד דוגמה אחרת עשתה: הביאה לפניו תינוקות בקומה אחת ובכסות אחד, אמרה לו 'הפרש לי מאלו זכרים ונקבות'. רמז לסריסיו, והביאו לו אגוזים וקליות, התחיל מפזרם לפניהם; זכרים, שלא היו מתביישים, היו נוטלים בבגדיהם, ונקבות, שהיו מתביישות, היו נוטלות בסודריהן. אמר לה 'אלו זכרים ואלו נקבות'. אמרה לו 'בני, חכם גדול אתה!'. ועוד דוגמה אחרת עשתה: הביאה ערלים ומהולים, אמרה לו 'הפרש לי המהולים מן הערלים'; מייד רמז לכהן גדול ופתח ארון הברית, מהולין שבהן כרעו בחצי קומתן, ולא עוד אלא שנתמלא פניהם מזיו השכינה, וערלים שבהן נופלים על פניהם, מייד אמר לה 'אלו ערלים ואלו מהולים'. אמרה לו 'מהיכן לך?' אמר לה 'מבלעם, דכתיב (במדבר כד ד): "אשר מחזה שדי יחזה נופל וגלוי עיניים", אילו לא היה נופל - לא היה רואה כלום. ואם אין אתה רוצה ללמוד מבלעם, בוא ולמד מאיוב: בשעה שבאו שלושת רעי איוב לנחמו, אמר להם (איוב יב ג): "גם לי לבב כמוכם, לא נופל אנוכי מכם", לא נופל אנוכי כמותכם'. באותה שעה אמרה לו (מלכים א י ז): "לא האמנתי לדברים עד אשר באתי ותראינה עיניי, והנה לא הוגד לי החצי, הוספת חכמה וטוב אל השמועה אשר שמעתי; אשרי אנשיך, אשרי עבדיך אלה העומדים לפניך תמיד השומעים את חכמתך; יהי ה' אלקיך ברוך אשר חפץ בך לתתך על כסא ישראל וגו' וישימך למלך לעשות משפט וצדקה".

These four tests are consistently quoted. More are added by some, such as the Targum Sheni and the 19 riddles from the Midrash Ha-Hefez, but these tests consistently show up in all sources. The Legends of the Jews combines those of the Targum Sheni and Midrash Ha-Hefez:

(58) Benaiah conducted the queen to Solomon, who had gone to sit in a house of glass to receive her. The queen was deceived by an illusion. She thought the king was sitting in water, and as she stepped across to him she raised her garment to keep it dry. On her bared feet the king noticed hair, and he said to her: "Thy beauty is the beauty of a woman, but thy hair is masculine; hair is an ornament to a man, but it disfigures a woman."

(59) Then the queen began and said: "I have heard of thee and thy wisdom; if now I inquire of thee concerning a matter, wilt thou answer me?" He replied: "The Lord giveth wisdom, out of His mouth cometh knowledge and understanding." She then said to him:

(60) 1. "Seven there are that issue and nine that enter; two yield the draught and one drinks." Said he to her: "Seven are the days of a woman's defilement, and nine the months of pregnancy; two are the breasts that yield the draught, and one the child that drinks it." Whereupon she said to him: "Thou art wise."

(61) 2. Then she questioned him further: "A woman said to her son, thy father is my father, and thy grandfather my husband; thou art my son, and I am thy sister." "Assuredly," said he, "it was the daughter of Lot who spake thus to her son."

(62) 3. She placed a number of males and females of the same stature and garb before him and said: "Distinguish between them." Forthwith he made a sign to the eunuchs, who brought him a quantity of nuts and roasted ears of corn. The males, who were not bashful, seized them with bare hands; the females took them, putting forth their gloved hands from beneath their garments. Whereupon he exclaimed: "Those are the males, these the females."

(63) 4. She brought a number of men to him, some circumcised and others uncircumcised, and asked him to distinguish between them. He immediately made a sign to the high priest, who opened the Ark of the covenant, whereupon those that were circumcised bowed their bodies to half their height, while their countenances were filled with the radiance of the Shekinah; the uncircumcised fell prone upon their faces. "Those," said he, "are circumcised, these uncircumcised." "Thou art wise, indeed," she exclaimed.

(64) 5. She put other questions to him, to all of which he gave replies. "Who is he who neither was born nor has died?" "It is the Lord of the world, blessed be He."

(65) 6. "What land is that which has but once seen the sun?" "The land upon which, after the creation, the waters were gathered, and the bed of the Red Sea on the day when it was divided."

(66) 7. "There is an enclosure with ten doors, when one is open, nine are shut; when nine are open, one is shut?" "That enclosure is the womb; the ten doors are the ten orifices of man his eyes, ears, nostrils, mouth, the apertures for the discharge of the excreta and the urine, and the navel; when the child is in the embryonic state, the navel is open and the other orifices are closed, but when it issues from the womb, the navel is closed and the others are opened."

(67) 8. "There is something which when living moves not, yet when its head is cut off it moves?" "It is the ship in the sea."

(68) 9. "Which are the three that neither ate, nor did they drink, nor did they have bread put into them, yet they saved lives from death?" "The signet, the cord, and the staff are those three."

(69) 10. "Three entered a cave and five came forth therefrom?" "Lot and his two daughters and their two children."

(70) 11. "The dead lived, the grave moved, and the dead prayed: what is that?" "The dead that lived and prayed, Jonah; and the fish, the moving grave."

(71) 12. "Who were the three that ate and drank on the earth, and yet were not born of male and female?" "The three angels who visited Abraham."

(72) 13. "Four entered a place of death and came forth alive, and two entered a place of life and came forth dead?" "The four were Daniel, Hananiah, Mishael, and Azariah, and the two were Nadab and Abihu."

(73) 14. "Who was he that was born and died not?" "Elijah and the Messiah."

(74) 15. "What was that which was not born, yet life was given to it?" "The golden calf."

(75) 16. "What is that which is produced from the ground, yet man produces it, while its food is the fruit of the ground?" "A wick."

(76) 17. "A woman was wedded to two, and bore two sons, yet these four had one father?" "Tamar."

(77) 18. "A house full of dead; no dead one came among them, nor did a living come forth from them?" "It is the story of Samson and the Philistines."

(78) 19. The queen next ordered the sawn trunk of a cedar tree to be brought, and she asked Solomon to point out at which end the root had been and at which the branches. He bade her cast it into the water, when one end sank and the other floated upon the surface of the water. That part which sank was the root, and that which remained uppermost was the branch end. Then she said to him: "Thou exceedest in wisdom and goodness the fame which I heard, blessed be thy God!"

(79) The last three riddles which the Queen of Sheba put to Solomon were the following:

(80) 20. "What is this? A wooden well with iron buckets, which draw stones and pour out water." The king replied: "A rouge-tube."

(81) 21. "What is this? It comes as dust from the earth, its food is dust, it is poured out like water, and lights the house." "Naphtha."

(82) 22. "What is this? It walks ahead of all; it cries out loud and bitterly; its head is like the reed; it is the glory of the noble, the disgrace of the poor; the glory of the dead, the disgrace of the living; the delight of birds, the distress of fishes." He answered: "Flax."

Almost all of the riddles, but especially the first four, are centered around a knowledge of Torah and Goyim, which leads credence to the sources that say she then converted. They also have a common focus on gender, a focus which starts even before she starts asking questions, as Shlomo points out the hairiness of her legs. The first riddle focuses on women, the second and third on both genders, and the fourth on men. As Tamar Kadari (PhD in Midrash studies from Hebrew University, Professor at Bar Ilan) points out:

The riddles that the Queen of Sheba put to Solomon attest to familiarity with the stories of the Torah, and especially with those about Gentiles (the daughters of Lot, Balaam and Job). The queen’s interest in Jewish culture is consistent with the tradition that her encounter with Solomon led to her conversion to Judaism (see below). The main shared element of all her riddles is that they are concerned with gender: the first focuses on women, the two middle riddles relate to males and females, and the fourth, to men. The first riddle pertains to the female’s birth cycle: menstruation, pregnancy, birth, and nursing. The riddle is elusive, since its verbs are couched in the masculine: “yozim [issue] … nikhnasim [enter] … mozgim [offer drink],” and Solomon’s wisdom is patent in his discovery of the solution in feminine matters. The second riddle is about the family unit. It threatens the generational hierarchy within the family, by interchanging father and grandfather, husband and father, mother and sister. The solution restores the normal order, since it reveals that this is an exceptional case, which held good only for the daughters of Lot. The third riddle indicates the differences between males and females that are already noticeable in young children, and is connected to the shame felt by girls at publicly exposing parts of their bodies; Solomon’s wisdom is evident in his knowledge of human nature. The last riddle regards male sexuality and distinguishes between someone who underwent circumcision and one who remained uncircumcised. Solomon shows that this physical difference has spiritual consequences, since these two groups exhibit disparate religious behavior. King Solomon’s ability to answer the queen’s four questions is indicative of his wisdom, since he is as cognizant of female nature as of the male character.

The Queen of Sheba, in every tradition, is important because of her own wisdom. She knows when to react and when not to, at Shlomo's summons, but not at his comments. She knows when to ignore advice, that of her council, but also when to embrace it, as she converts. Her questions are specific and pointed, and she knows what to look for to prove Shlomo's divine intelligence. She's held in extremely high regard:

(ד) דָּבָר אַחֵר, וַיִּשְׁמַע יִתְרוֹ, הֲדָא הוּא דִכְתִיב (ירמיה טז, יט): ה' עֻזִּי וּמָעֻזִּי וּמְנוּסִי בְּיוֹם צָרָה אֵלֶיךָ גּוֹיִם יָבֹאוּ מֵאַפְסֵי אָרֶץ, אָמְרוּ יִשְׂרָאֵל לְהַקָּדוֹשׁ בָּרוּךְ הוּא כְּשֶׁעָשִׂיתָ לָנוּ נִסִּים בַּיָּם אָמַרְנוּ לְךָ (שמות טו, ב): עָזִּי וְזִמְרָת יָהּ, הֲלוֹא שָׁמְעָה רָחָב וּבָאָה וְדָבְקָה בָךְ, שֶׁנֶּאֱמַר (יהושע ב, ט י): וַתֹּאמֶר אֶל הָאֲנָשִׁים יָדַעְתִּי כִּי נָתַן ה' לָכֶם אֶת הָאָרֶץ, כִּי שָׁמַעְנוּ אֵת אֲשֶׁר הוֹבִישׁ ה' אֶת מֵי יַם סוּף, הֱוֵי: ה' עֻזִּי וּמָעֻזִּי וּמְנוּסִי בְּיוֹם צָרָה. כְּשֶׁעָשִׂיתָ נִסִּים בִּימֵי שְׁלֹמֹה, שֶׁנֶּאֱמַר (שמואל א ב, י): וְיִתֶּן עֹז לְמַלְכּוֹ, לֹא בָאת מַלְכַּת שְׁבָא וְשִׁבְּחָה אוֹתְךָ, שֶׁנֶּאֱמַר (מלכים א י, א): וּמַלְכַּת שְׁבָא שֹׁמַעַת אֶת שֵׁמַע שְׁלֹמֹה, וּמָה אָמְרָה (מלכים א י, ט): יְהִי ה' אֱלֹקֶיךָ בָּרוּךְ אֲשֶׁר חָפֵץ בְּךָ. כְּשֶׁהוֹצֵאתָ אוֹתָנוּ מִמִּצְרַיִם וְנָתַתָּ לָנוּ אֶת הַתּוֹרָה שֶׁנִּקְרֵאת עֹז, שֶׁנֶּאֱמַר (תהלים כט, יא): ה' עֹז לְעַמּוֹ יִתֵּן, וְלֹא שָׁמַע יִתְרוֹ וּבָא וְנִדְבַּק בָּךְ, הֱוֵי: אֵלֶיךָ גּוֹיִם יָבֹאוּ מֵאַפְסֵי אָרֶץ.

The Queen of Sheba is compared to Rachav and Yisro, she came to Judaism because of the miracles of Hashem and the greatness of the Jewish people. Just like Rachav and Yisro, she found Hashem, but unlike Rachav and Yisro, she leaves again. Yisro and Rachav's descendants join or live with the nation, but the Queen of Sheba goes back to Sheba. There are some Ethiopian traditions that believe that Ethiopian Jewry is descended from her, but otherwise, she seems to have lost her Yiddishkeit upon return.

Rabbi Dovid Rosenfeld, of Aish, quotes the lost Midrash about Nevuchnezzad being descended from the Queen, and points out this failure on Shlomo's part. The Pasuk says he gave her all she desired, but didn't bring her fully to Hashem. He then allowed her to leave, and, not fully connected and without support, she didn't stay faithful. "The energy he invested into the relationship would not bring the world closer to salvation but would remain distant – and would ultimately be used against the sanctity of Solomon’s world and destroy his Temple."

We learn from the Queen of Sheba that no matter your background or wisdom or power, separating oneself from the Klal leads to your downfall. No matter how strong a connection to Judaism you have have, you can't do it alone.